How to Choose Smart Waterproof Boots (Town, Office and Country)

The short answer

Choose by where you'll walk. For town and the office, a leather Chelsea or lace-up ankle boot with a waterproof lining and a grippy rubber sole looks smartest. For fields and festivals, choose a slim rubber ankle welly. Check the seams, tongue, tread and height, then wear them with cropped trousers or midi skirts.

EVELYSS sleek black leather waterproof Chelsea boots with a low heel under dark straight trousers — Ms. Evelyss, AI-generated fashion muse.

“Waterproof boots can look smart; most just aren't designed to. Look at the shape before anything else. A slim toe, a clean upper and a sole that doesn't shout 'hiking' will take you from the platform to the meeting.”Her take

What does waterproof actually mean on a boot?

Waterproof and water-resistant are not the same thing. A water-resistant boot, such as leather treated with a proofing spray, will shrug off a shower but can let water in when you stand in a puddle. A waterproof boot is built to keep water out: it is either made of rubber or has a waterproof membrane lining inside the upper.

When you read a description or look at the boot in a shop, check how it's made, not just the word on the label. The details below are what keep your feet dry.

A waterproof membrane lining or a fully rubber construction.
A gusseted tongue, joined to the sides of the boot, so water can't get in through the lacing.
Sealed or few seams on the lower part of the boot, where it meets the wet ground.
A shaft high enough for the puddles you actually walk through.
On a Chelsea boot, a lining that runs up behind the elastic side panels, which are otherwise where water gets in first.

Which waterproof boot style is smartest?

Each style has a place. The smartest for everyday town life is a leather Chelsea boot with a waterproof lining; the most waterproof is rubber. Use this to match the boot to your week.

Leather Chelsea boot with a waterproof lining: smartest; town, office and commuting. Easy on and off, but water can get in at the top in deep puddles.
Leather lace-up ankle boot: smart casual; city walking and weekends. Good support; make sure the tongue is gusseted.
Rubber ankle welly or rubber Chelsea: casual but neat; country, school run and festivals. Fully waterproof, doesn't breathe, so wear wool socks.
Tall leather boot with a waterproof lining: smart; town and the races. Great with skirts; check the calf fits over tights and socks.
Tall rubber welly: practical; fields and deep mud. Rarely smart in town.
Treated suede: not for regular rain; proofing helps, but suede still spots.

How do you check the sole and grip?

Turn the boot over. A rubber sole with a defined tread grips wet pavements, leaves and station floors far better than a smooth sole, and smooth leather soles can be slippery on wet stone.

For a smart look, choose a sole with a moderate tread rather than deep hiking lugs, and a low block heel rather than a stiletto. The sole should flex where your foot bends; a sole that is rigid all the way along is tiring on a long walk.

How should waterproof boots fit?

Try boots on with the socks or tights you'll actually wear with them in winter. Thicker socks can take up a surprising amount of room, so you need space to wiggle your toes without your heel lifting as you walk.

With rubber boots, a little room is normal, but too much and your heel will slip and rub. With tall boots, check the calf with tights and with thicker socks, and make sure the shaft doesn't dig in behind the knee when you sit down.

What should you wear with waterproof boots to look smart?

Cropped or ankle-length trousers that end just above the boot, or slim trousers tucked in, keep the line clean and your hems dry. With skirts and dresses, a midi length and opaque tights in the same colour as the boot make the leg look long and finished.

Black, dark brown and burgundy are the most versatile colours. A long coat that overlaps the top of a tall boot, with no gap of leg, looks the most polished of all.

How do you keep leather boots waterproof?

Brush off mud once it's dry, or wipe it away with a damp cloth. Let wet boots dry slowly at room temperature, stuffed with newspaper to keep their shape, never on a radiator or by a fire, which can crack the leather.

Re-proof leather with a product made for that material when water stops beading on the surface, and condition it now and then so it stays supple. Wipe away pavement salt marks with a damp cloth as soon as you notice them.

Questions people ask

Are Chelsea boots waterproof?

Only if they're made of rubber or have a waterproof lining that runs behind the elastic sides. Standard leather Chelsea boots are water-resistant at best, and the elastic panels are where water usually gets in.

Can suede boots be made waterproof?

A proofing spray makes suede more water-resistant, but not waterproof. It still spots in heavy rain, so keep suede for drier days.

Can you wear wellies to the office?

A slim, dark rubber ankle boot can pass in a relaxed office. For most workplaces, wear them on the commute and change at your desk.

Should I size up for winter socks?

Not automatically. Try boots on with your thickest winter socks and choose the size where your toes can move and your heel stays put.

Can waterproof boots have a heel?

Yes. A low block heel with a rubber sole keeps its grip on wet pavements and looks smart with skirts and tailored trousers.

The takeaway

Waterproof means a lining or rubber, not a spray; choose the style for where you walk, a treaded rubber sole and a low block heel, and wear them with cropped hems or a midi skirt and matching tights.

New looks, every day

Her shorts, the Sunday code word for her promo codes, and answers to your questions, on every platform as @msevelyss.

Ask her yours