How to Stop Mascara Smudging Under Your Eyes
Smudging usually comes from oil and moisture under the eyes, not the mascara alone. Keep eye cream light and let it absorb, press a little translucent powder under the eyes, curl your lashes, and apply thin coats mostly to the top lashes. If it still transfers, try a tubing formula or skip the lower lashes.
“Everyone blames the mascara, but the shadow under your eye is usually a story about what you put on before it. Fix the skin underneath and a mascara you thought was a smudger often turns out to be fine.”Her take
Why mascara ends up under your eyes
Mascara transfers when lashes touch skin that is oily or damp. Rich eye creams, creamy concealer, natural oil, warm rooms and watery eyes in the cold all soften the formula, and every blink presses your lashes against that slick surface.
Straight or downward-pointing lashes touch the skin more, and so do hooded or deep-set eyes. That's why the same mascara can be smudge-free on one person and a shadow by noon on another.
Prep the under-eye area first
Apply eye cream at least ten minutes before makeup, or switch to a lighter gel texture in the morning and keep the richer cream for night. Use only a small amount and tap away any excess.
Use the thinnest layer of concealer you need, then set it. Press a little translucent powder under the eyes with a small brush or the tip of a sponge, especially on the outer corners where lashes land. A light dusting is enough; heavy powder can settle into fine lines.
Apply mascara so it stays put
How you apply matters as much as which mascara you use.
- Curl your lashes first so they sit up and away from the skin.
- Wipe excess off the wand on the rim of the tube before each coat.
- Apply thin coats, wiggling at the root and pulling up to the tips; let each coat dry for 30 seconds or so.
- Concentrate on the top lashes. Lower lashes cause most of the smudging, so skip them or touch only the outer few lightly.
- Look down into a mirror while you apply to avoid touching your lid.
- Let it dry completely before you blink hard or touch your face.
Which mascara formulas smudge least?
Tubing mascaras wrap each lash in a polymer coat that holds up against oil better than traditional formulas, so they resist smudging well, and they loosen with warm water and gentle pressure. Waterproof formulas resist tears, rain and humidity but need an oil-based remover, and they can still soften with oily skin.
If you love a regular mascara, use it on top of a coat of tubing or waterproof mascara, or keep the regular one for top lashes only. A lash primer can help lashes hold the formula, though it adds a step.
Winter, watery eyes and long days
Cold wind makes many people's eyes water, which is a common reason smudging gets worse in winter. Waterproof or tubing mascara is worth switching to for cold-weather days, games and holiday markets.
Avoid rubbing your eyes. If they water, blot gently at the inner and outer corners with a tissue rather than wiping across.
How to fix a smudge midday
Don't rub it. Dip a cotton swab in a tiny amount of moisturizer or micellar water, roll it over the smudge, then follow with a dry swab. Tap a little concealer back on if needed and set with a touch of powder.
If it happens every day, keep the fix in your bag: a few swabs and a mini powder take less than a minute.
Questions people ask
Why does my waterproof mascara still smudge?
Waterproof resists water but can break down with oil. Use less eye cream, set the under-eye area with powder, or try a tubing formula.
Should I put mascara on my bottom lashes?
Only if it stays. Bottom lashes cause most smudging. Try just the outer few, or define the lower lash line with a long-wear pencil instead.
Does setting spray help mascara?
A light mist of setting spray on the face can help makeup stay put overall, but powder under the eyes is the more direct fix for transfer.
How often should I replace mascara?
The usual advice is about every three months from opening. Replace it sooner if it smells off or turns dry and flaky, because flaky mascara also leaves specks under the eyes.
The takeaway
Light eye cream, a powder barrier, curled lashes, thin coats on the top lashes, and a tubing or waterproof formula when your eyes water.
Read next
New looks, every day
Her shorts, the Sunday code word for her promo codes, and answers to your questions, on every platform as @msevelyss.
Ask her yours